When it comes to preserving your Cleveland home’s curb appeal and structural integrity, few improvements make as significant an impact as siding replacement. Whether your home has suffered damage from Ohio’s unpredictable weather or you’re just aiming for a fresh look, replacing old siding can increase energy efficiency, improve aesthetics, and enhance resale value. For those specifically seeking shake siding replacement in Cleveland, this comprehensive guide will walk you through the entire process—helping you make informed decisions and avoid costly mistakes.
Why Siding Replacement Matters in Cleveland
Cleveland’s climate subjects homes to a wide range of conditions—icy winters, humid summers, and heavy storms. Over time, these weather patterns can wear down your siding, leading to cracks, warping, mold growth, and energy loss. When you notice these signs, it’s time to consider a full replacement rather than temporary repairs.

Homeowners opting for shake siding replacement in Cleveland are often drawn to its rustic charm, natural wood appearance, and long-lasting durability. But regardless of the siding material you choose—vinyl, fiber cement, wood, or engineered wood—the replacement process follows similar critical steps.
Step 1: Evaluate the Condition of Your Existing Siding
Before anything else, inspect your home’s current siding for:
- Cracks or holes
- Mold or mildew
- Warping or buckling
- Increased energy bills
- Pest infestations
In many cases, these signs indicate that your siding has outlived its lifespan and needs to be replaced. If you’re unsure, hiring a professional for a siding inspection is a wise move.
Step 2: Choose the Right Siding Material
Choosing the appropriate siding for your Cleveland home is crucial. The climate, your budget, and your desired aesthetic all play a role. Popular siding materials include:
1. Vinyl Siding
- Affordable, low maintenance, and widely available.
- Comes in a variety of colors and textures.
2. Fiber Cement Siding
- Durable, fire-resistant, and mimics wood grain.
- Withstands Cleveland’s cold and moisture.
3. Wood Siding (Shake Siding)
- Beautiful and natural in appearance.
- Needs regular maintenance, but modern shake alternatives (like engineered wood or fiber cement shakes) offer the same look with less upkeep.
4. Engineered Wood Siding
- Resembles natural wood but with enhanced durability.
- Cost-effective and weather-resistant.
For homeowners looking to preserve historical charm or add character, shake siding replacement in Cleveland is a popular choice.
Step 3: Set Your Budget
Siding replacement is an investment. Here are a few cost factors:
- Material costs: Vinyl is more budget-friendly than fiber cement or engineered wood.
- Home size and layout: Complex architecture may increase labor.
- Labor costs: Professional installation ensures longevity but comes at a cost.
- Permits and disposal fees: Often required in Cleveland for construction work.
Make sure to get multiple quotes from local siding contractors to find the right balance between cost and quality.
Step 4: Remove the Existing Siding
Once you’ve chosen a contractor and material, the first physical step in the replacement process is removing the old siding. This includes:
- Stripping off the old panels or shakes.
- Inspecting the underlying wall sheathing for water damage or mold.
- Repairing any rot or decay found during the removal.
This is also a good time to upgrade wall insulation or install a house wrap to improve energy efficiency.
Step 5: Prepare the Walls for Installation
Proper wall preparation ensures the longevity of your new siding. Tasks may include:
- Installing a moisture barrier or house wrap to prevent water infiltration.
- Adding flashing around windows and doors.
- Installing starter strips and corner posts if using vinyl or engineered wood.
In Cleveland’s humid and storm-prone climate, this waterproofing step is especially important.
Step 6: Install the New Siding
Here’s where the transformation begins:
Vinyl or Engineered Wood Installation
- Panels are installed from the bottom up.
- Nailing should allow for expansion and contraction due to weather changes.
- Trim is applied around windows, doors, and corners.
Shake Siding Installation
- Can be installed in rows or staggered patterns for a more textured look.
- Often requires careful cutting and nailing to maintain symmetry.
- May be painted or stained post-installation, depending on the product.
Proper installation is key to avoiding issues like warping, moisture penetration, or misaligned seams.
Step 7: Paint or Seal (If Needed)
While vinyl and prefinished fiber cement siding don’t usually require painting, wood shakes or unfinished fiber cement might. Consider:
- Stain or paint quality: Choose UV- and moisture-resistant options.
- Color matching: Make sure your new siding complements your roof, trim, and landscape.
This step adds a layer of protection and boosts curb appeal.
Step 8: Perform a Final Inspection
Before closing the project, perform a thorough inspection:
- Check for uniformity in spacing and alignment.
- Confirm caulking around windows and trim.
- Look for any loose panels or exposed nails.
It’s a good idea to walk through the finished project with your contractor to ensure all expectations are met.
Step 9: Clean Up and Dispose of Old Materials
A professional contractor should handle the disposal of your old siding, nails, and other debris. Ask if the company recycles old materials—it’s an environmentally responsible option.
Step 10: Maintain Your New Siding
Even the best siding requires periodic maintenance to stay in top condition:
- Wash annually with a mild detergent and water.
- Inspect caulking and flashing for cracks or gaps.
- Trim nearby trees to prevent mold or mildew growth.
If you opted for shake siding replacement in Cleveland, plan to restain or reseal every few years unless you chose a low-maintenance composite or fiber cement shake product.

Final Thoughts: Choosing the Right Partner
Siding replacement is more than just a facelift for your home—it’s a long-term investment in durability, comfort, and beauty. By following this step-by-step guide, Cleveland homeowners can approach the process with confidence.
But choosing the right contractor is just as important as choosing the right materials. For Cleveland residents looking for quality workmanship, reliable timelines, and durable siding solutions—including shake siding replacement in Cleveland—look no further than Atlas Roofing & Restoration. With years of local experience, our team ensures every siding project is done right the first time. Reach out today for a free estimate and expert consultation tailored to your home’s unique needs.